If you last shopped at Abercrombie & Fitch when it meant dark stores, loud music and big moose logos, the brand today will feel very different. A&F now sells grown-up denim, workwear-style trousers and soft loungewear, and it’s aimed at shoppers in their twenties and thirties rather than teenagers.
The change has won over some unlikely fans. A MEL Magazine piece found that members of r/MaleFashionAdvice, a community of more than 3.5 million, now see the brand as “good now in terms of both quality and value.” Women’s denim, especially the Curve Love fit, gets much of the credit. melmagazine
The shopping experience is less popular. Shoppers on Trustpilot describe hard-to-reach customer service and slow refunds, and you pay $7 to send a return by mail.
This review is based on research, not hands-on testing. It covers three of A&F’s most popular pieces with current prices, how they fit, what myAbercrombie gets you, and how A&F’s shipping and returns compare with a similar mall brand.
About Abercrombie & Fitch
Abercrombie & Fitch sells jeans, trousers, tops, sweaters, loungewear, outerwear and fragrance for women and men, plus kids’ clothing under the abercrombie kids label. It’s owned by Abercrombie & Fitch Co., the same company behind Hollister.
At the time of checking, the US homepage offered free standard shipping and handling on orders over $99, plus 15% off the entire purchase for signing up by email, with exclusions. There are clearance sections for women and men, and some clearance items carry an extra 15% off in the bag. The brand’s loyalty program is called myAbercrombie. It’s free to join, and big spenders get bumped up to VIP, which adds free shipping and a longer return window.
Highlights:
- Price range: about $49–$90 for the pieces covered here, with clearance markdowns
- Signature fit: Curve Love jeans, with an extra 2 inches through the hip and thigh
- Shipping: free standard shipping on orders over $99; $7 below that
- Returns: 30 days for a refund; 60 days for VIP members, with store credit after day 30
- Mail return fee: $7, deducted from your refund; in-store returns are free
- Holiday returns: items bought Nov. 1 to Dec. 31 can be returned through Jan. 31
Pros
- Curve Love jeans are widely praised for fixing the gap at the back of the waist.
- Jeans come in several lengths, including Extra Short and Extra Long.
- Denim is mostly cotton, with 1% elastane in the styles covered here.
- Returns and exchanges are free in US stores.
- VIP members get free standard shipping on every order.
Cons
- Mail returns cost $7.
- Free shipping starts at $99 for regular members.
- Trustpilot gives A&F a 1.8 out of 5 rating.
- Some reviewers report pilling on loungewear and basics.
- Curve Love sizing varies from style to style.
Abercrombie & Fitch Product Reviews
Two parts of the A&F site do most of the selling: the denim wall and the Sunday loungewear collection. Almost every item in those sections carries a “Top Rated” badge, and the product grids show how many people bought each one recently. These picks are the most-bought styles from each section, one pair of jeans for women and one for men, plus the hoodie at the center of the Sunday sets.

Curve Love High Rise 90s Relaxed Jean
This is the jean most people mean when they talk about the A&F rebrand. A&F says its Curve Love fit is designed with an additional 2" through the hip and thigh, to stop the waist from gapping. The jeans are made from A&F’s Vintage Comfort Stretch denim, with a body of 99% cotton and 1% elastane. Inseams are listed as Short 29.50", Regular 31.50", Long 33.50", with Extra Short and Extra Long options too.
Independent reviewers are mostly positive. A Refinery29 writer who wore a size 36W said the Curve Love fit was one of the best I’ve tried in a long time, and that the waist gap she usually gets was noticeably reduced. A Reviewed.com writer said the Curve Love pair had become the most-worn jeans in her wardrobe.
The catch is sizing. Zappos reviewers of different Curve Love styles disagree on whether to size up or down. One said a pair run very small and suggested going up 1–2 sizes, while others went down a size. If you’re new to Curve Love, order two sizes and return one in store.
$54.99 $90.00 39% off

90s Straight Jean
This men’s jean is described as “straight through the thigh and leg with a slightly higher rise.” The body fabric is 99% Cotton, 1% Elastane, so it should feel close to rigid denim with a little give. It comes in 12 colors, and lengths run from 28 to 34.
In the men’s jeans grid, this light wash was showing a “Top Rated” badge and 61 people purchased, the highest count among the first products listed. The page’s customer fit summary says it fits true to size.
The catch is that the page doesn’t show a numeric rise or leg opening, so it’s hard to compare with jeans you already own. At $80 with no discount, it’s also more than American Eagle charges for its stretch jeans on sale. If you want a looser shape, A&F’s Baggy Jean costs $90.
$80.00

Sunday Popover Hoodie
The Sunday Popover Hoodie is the centerpiece of A&F’s Sunday Sets collection, which pairs hoodies, sweatshirts and cardigans with matching sweatpants. The fabric is 70% cotton, 30% recycled polyester, and A&F describes the fit as drop-shoulder with a banded hem and cuffs. It comes in 16 colors, in sizes XXS to XXL.
The hoodie was one of the best-selling items in the Sunday collection, with several colors showing 60 to 70 recent purchases each. The page’s customer fit note says it fits true to size, and the size S body length is listed at 25 inches. The matching Essential Sunday High Rise Wide Leg Sweatpant costs $65.
The catch is durability. Thingtesting’s summary of A&F reviews notes sizing variance on loungewear and occasional pilling. At the $49 sale price it’s fair value, but $70 is a lot for a cotton-poly hoodie that may pill.
$49 $70.00 30% off
Who Is Abercrombie & Fitch For?
A&F makes the most sense if you’re a woman with a small waist and fuller hips who struggles to find jeans that fit both. The Curve Love line and the range of lengths are its biggest strengths, and reviewers who are tall, short or plus-size often mention them.
It’s also a good fit if you want a polished casual wardrobe without paying designer prices. The jeans, Sloane tailored trousers and Sunday sets are built for people who want to look put together on a normal weekday.
You might want to look elsewhere if you’re on a tight budget or don’t live near a store. Regular prices sit around $70–$90, free shipping starts at $99, and mail returns cost $7. Shoppers who live far from a store pay more to fix sizing mistakes.
Abercrombie & Fitch vs American Eagle
American Eagle is the closest comparison, since both brands are built around jeans and casual basics. A&F leans more polished and premium, while AE is cheaper and more focused on stretch.
Returns cost a little more at A&F. Abercrombie & Fitch: $7 fee to return by mail or free in-store returns, while American Eagle charges $5 to return by mail for most items, according to The Motley Fool. AE also offers free standard shipping from $75, compared with A&F’s $99.
The denim is different too. The A&F jeans covered here are 99% cotton, while AE’s AirFlex+ jeans are known for their stretch. If you want a vintage-style jean that holds its shape, A&F is the better pick. If you want soft stretch at around $30 on sale, AE usually wins on price.
What Do Customers Say?
Opinions split depending on where you look.
On Trustpilot, checked in November 2026, Abercrombie & Fitch has a TrustScore of 1.8 out of 5 (“Poor”) from 691 reviews, and 69% of them are 1-star. The profile is unclaimed. Reviewers there mention customer service is hard to reach, with long waits and automated chats, along with delayed refunds and stock problems.
Thingtesting, a brand-review site, is much kinder. It shows A&F at 4.2, with 89% of reviewers would recommend to a friend. Reviews there praise durable denim and Curve Love fits, but its summary also flags inconsistent quality in certain items (e.g., Sloan pants pilling, bodysuits that pill).
Common praise: Curve Love jeans, a range of lengths for tall and short shoppers, soft basics, and better quality since the rebrand. A few Trustpilot reviewers also say refunds came through quickly.
Common complaints: Slow or hard-to-reach customer service, delayed refunds, pilling on loungewear and bodysuits, inconsistent sizing between styles, and a ConsumerAffairs reviewer who said two sweaters had broken zippers after seven months.
“I find that for fast fashion, Abercrombie is pretty high quality.” — Reviewer on Thingtesting
“Not worth the hassle. Will buy nicer clothes elsewhere from here on out.” — Karen Kusserow, Trustpilot, November 2026
Shipping & Returns Policies
Shipping.
Standard shipping is free on online orders over $99 within the US. Below that, the product pages list standard shipping at $7 and Two Day at $15. For standard delivery, A&F says to allow 4-9 business days, and up to 14 days in some areas.
myAbercrombie VIP members get free shipping on every order. A&F’s FAQ says that for VIP members, you will earn standard free shipping on all your orders. You reach VIP by spending $500 in a membership year.
Returns.
You get 30 days from the estimated or actual delivery date, whichever is later, to return online orders for a full refund. VIP myAbercrombie members receive an additional 30 days, for a total of 60 days to make returns, but anything returned after day 30 only gets merchandise credit.
The fee depends on how you return. In-store returns and exchanges are free at any US Abercrombie & Fitch or abercrombie kids store, as long as you bring your receipt, invoice or order confirmation. Mail returns cost $7, which comes out of your refund. If you’re sending back items from several orders, you can put them in one package and you will only be charged the $7 return fee once.
Once A&F starts your refund, it may take 3-5 business days to appear in your account. There’s also a holiday extension: with proof of purchase, merchandise purchased between November 1 and December 31 may be returned for a full refund through January 31.
In stores, A&F also offers a price adjustment. If an item you bought drops in price within 7 days of the date of your purchase, you can bring it in with the receipt and get the difference back.
Is Abercrombie & Fitch Worth It?
For jeans, yes, especially if regular brands don’t fit your waist and hips at the same time. The Curve Love line has strong independent reviews, and the mostly-cotton denim is closer to vintage jeans than most mall brands.
It’s less clear for loungewear and basics at full price. The Sunday hoodie is good value at $49, but several review sites mention pilling, and $70 is a lot to pay if it doesn’t last.
The bigger issue is service. If you get your size right, or live near a store, you’ll avoid most of the problems. If you’re ordering online and unsure of your size, the $7 return fee and slow customer service can make A&F frustrating. Wait for sales, which come around often, and check clearance before paying full price.
Where to Buy Abercrombie & Fitch?
You can buy from abercrombie.com, the A&F app, or Abercrombie & Fitch and abercrombie kids stores. Ordering online and returning in store is the cheapest way to try sizes.
Some A&F pieces also show up on Zappos, where you can read extra customer reviews. Clearance sections on abercrombie.com often have older colors of popular jeans at a big discount.
If you shop A&F a lot, join myAbercrombie. Members earn 10 points per $1, and 2,500 points turn into a $10 reward. It’s free, and reaching VIP removes the shipping minimum.
FAQs:
What is Abercrombie & Fitch’s return policy?
You have 30 days from delivery to return online orders for a full refund. VIP myAbercrombie members get 60 days, but returns after day 30 only get merchandise credit.
Does Abercrombie charge for returns?
Mail returns cost $7, deducted from your refund. Returning in a US store is free, including for online orders.
Does Abercrombie & Fitch have free shipping?
Standard shipping is free on US orders over $99. VIP myAbercrombie members get free standard shipping on every order.
Do Curve Love jeans run big or small?
It depends on the style. Many reviewers say they fit true to size, but some go down a size and others say certain styles run small, so check the reviews for the exact style you want.
What is myAbercrombie?
It’s A&F’s free rewards program. Members earn 10 points per $1, and 2,500 points become a $10 reward. Spending $500 in a year unlocks VIP perks.
What is Abercrombie’s holiday return policy?
Items bought between November 1 and December 31 can be returned for a full refund through January 31. You’ll need the receipt, invoice or order confirmation.
Is Abercrombie & Fitch good quality now?
Many reviewers say quality has improved since the rebrand, especially for denim. Some report pilling on bodysuits and loungewear, so quality isn’t the same across every category.
Final Verdict: Is Abercrombie Worth Shopping Again?
Abercrombie & Fitch is a good choice if you want well-fitting jeans and polished basics, and you’re willing to shop sales. The Curve Love jeans are its strongest product, and they’ve earned genuine praise from shoppers who usually struggle with denim.
Be careful if you mostly shop online and live far from a store. The $7 mail return fee, the $99 free-shipping threshold and reports of hard-to-reach customer service all make mistakes more costly. The best place to start is the Curve Love High Rise 90s Relaxed Jean, ideally on clearance. For men, the 90s Straight Jean is A&F’s most-bought style. If you’re between sizes, order both and return one in store for free.



