Banana Republic is the most expensive of Gap Inc.’s main brands, sitting above Gap and Old Navy. For years it was the go-to store for office clothes, and in recent seasons it has pushed harder into natural fabrics like cashmere, merino wool and linen.
The new direction has fans. A Business Insider writer who compared sweaters across Gap Inc.’s brands said of all the sweaters I tried on, the version from Banana Republic was my favorite. A style blogger who had sent back cashmere over poor construction a year earlier now calls the brand’s latest collection worth a look.
Not everyone agrees. Shoppers on Reddit, Slickdeals and Trustpilot regularly say quality has slipped, and full prices of $120–$160 for basics feel high when the same items go on sale so often.
This review is based on research, not hands-on testing. It covers three popular Banana Republic pieces with current prices, how they fit, how the shared Encore rewards work, and how BR compares with Quince.
About Banana Republic
Banana Republic sells workwear, knitwear, trousers, coats, dresses, shoes and accessories for women and men. Its current homepage leans into holiday pieces like Fair Isle sweaters, shearling jackets, Italian wool tailoring, and cashmere layers.
Cashmere is a big focus. BR says select styles meet The Good Cashmere Standard™, and its women’s sweater page lists cashmere crews from $160 up to nearly $400.
Sales are frequent. At the time of checking, the homepage offered an extra 20% off sale styles for women and men, and some full-price items had extra discounts at checkout.
Highlights:
- Price range: about $85–$160 for the pieces covered here, with frequent sales
- Signature products: cashmere sweaters, Traveler pants, Rapid Movement chinos
- Shipping: free on $50+ for Encore rewards members
- Returns: 30 days, with longer windows for higher Encore tiers
- Return shipping: free for Encore members; $6 for non-members
- Member perk: free basic hemming for All-Access cardmembers
Pros
- Many sweaters are 100% cashmere or merino wool.
- The Slim Traveler Pant has over 1,300 ratings averaging 4.8 stars.
- Sales and checkout discounts often cut prices by 40% or more.
- Encore is free and includes free mail returns.
- All-Access cardmembers get free basic hemming on pants, skirts and dresses.
Cons
- Full prices are high for mall-brand basics.
- Some cashmere reviewers report pilling after one or two wears.
- Trustpilot gives Banana Republic a 1.8 out of 5 rating.
- Several long-time shoppers say quality has declined over the years.
- Non-members pay $6 to return items by mail.
Banana Republic Product Reviews
Banana Republic’s reputation rests on two things: knitwear and work trousers. These picks include two of its most-reviewed cashmere crew-necks, one deeply discounted and one at full price, plus the Slim Traveler Pant, the men’s pant with the most reviews on the site.

Cashmere Crew-Neck Sweater
This is one of BR’s core cashmere sweaters. It’s 100% cashmere, 12-gauge knit, with a tapered fit that has room through the shoulders with a fit that narrows from chest to hem. It comes in Regular and Tall, in sizes XS to XXL.
The page shows 4.7 out of 5 stars from 458 ratings. One reviewer wrote that they had tried all the cashmere sweaters of competing brands at a similar price point, including Uniqlo, Quince and J.Crew, and found BR’s better.
The catch is thickness and durability. One 1-star reviewer said it was so thin it rolled up on its own, and another reported a hole forming “above the waist from just normal wear” after about three months. At $84.99, with an extra 20% off at checkout, it’s a fair price for pure cashmere. At $160, you’d be better off waiting.
$160.00

Lightweight Cashmere Crew-Neck Sweater
This is the sweater PureWow named its Best Overall Cashmere Sweater in its 2026 guide, and Business Insider’s tester said I loved everything about the Banana Republic sweater. It’s 100% cashmere, made to The Good Cashmere Standard, with a classic fit, straight and easy through the body that hits at the hip.
The page shows 4.5 out of 5 stars from 413 ratings. A 5-star reviewer said it “Fits great, not itchy at all.”
The catch is pilling. One 3-star reviewer reported pilling “after just one wear,” and another compared the quality to Quince’s $50 cashmere. The page also lists lower prices for some colors, so check your color before paying full price.
$160.00

Slim Traveler Pant
The Traveler Pant is BR’s best-known men’s trouser. The fabric is 58% organic cotton, 32% modal, 7% polyester, 3% elastane, from Italy’s Olimpias mill. The fit has an 11-inch front rise and a 14.25-inch leg opening, in waists from 29 to 40 and lengths 30, 32 and 34.
It’s one of the best-rated items on the site, with 4.8 out of 5. The header shows 1,349 ratings. One 5-star reviewer said it works for both job sites and client meetings, and a 4-star reviewer praised its wrinkle resistance.
The catch is sizing and consistency. Some reviewers say it “Runs a tad small,” and one 1-star reviewer said the pants seemed downgraded and baggier than a previous pair. At $120 with no discount shown, it’s expensive, and BR’s own pants listings show Traveler styles regularly marked down below $65.
$120.00
Who Is Banana Republic For?
Banana Republic is a good fit for professionals who want polished, natural-fiber clothes without paying designer prices. If you need office trousers, cashmere sweaters or a good coat, it’s one of the better mall options.
It also works if you already shop Gap or Old Navy. Your Encore account carries over, and All-Access cardmembers get free basic alterations on eligible merchandise purchased at Banana Republic, which helps with trousers.
You might want to look elsewhere if you won’t wait for sales, or if you want the most cashmere for your money. Direct-to-consumer brands like Quince sell similar basics for much less at full price.
Banana Republic vs Quince
Quince is BR’s most common comparison for cashmere. Apartstyle notes that a Quince cashmere sweater at $80 is a stark contrast to a similar sweater at Banana Republic, which often starts at $150.
Sales narrow that gap. The same comparison says Banana Republic’s frequent 30-40% off sales can make their items very price-competitive, occasionally even less expensive than Quince on certain products. The Cashmere Crew-Neck at $84.99 shows exactly that.
The other difference is range. Apartstyle says BR offers good quality across a broader range of styles and fabrics, including wool blends, high-quality cotton, leather, and linen. If you want just a basic cashmere crew, Quince is cheaper. If you want tailoring, coats and trousers too, BR covers more ground.
What Do Customers Say?
Product reviews on bananarepublic.gap.com are strong. The Slim Traveler Pant averages 4.8 from more than 1,300 ratings, and the cashmere crews average 4.5–4.7 from over 400 each.
Independent reviews are much weaker. Checked in November 2026, Trustpilot shows Banana Republic with a TrustScore: 1.8 out of 5 (“Poor”) from 46 reviews, and 44% are 1-star. The profile is unclaimed, and the sample is small.
Common complaints: Trustpilot reviewers mention lost or delayed packages, and claims that are denied or hard to file, slow refunds, and declining quality and rising prices. On Slickdeals, one long-time shopper said BR’s quality had gone down tremendously in the last few years, though another commenter disagreed and pointed to better shoes and Italian fabrics.
Common praise: Reviewers mention good sales, friendly in-store staff, and soft natural fabrics. On Reddit, one shopper said they think BR’s quality has improved but that it isn’t worth full price, and they’d rarely pay more than $45 for chinos.
“Fits great, not itchy at all.” — Reviewer on BR’s Lightweight Cashmere Crew-Neck Sweater page
“The Quality is absolute Trash.” — Lisa Julien, Trustpilot, September 2026
Shipping, Returns & Warranty
Shipping. The product pages show free shipping is listed for $50+ for Rewards Members. Banana Republic uses the same Encore program as Gap and Old Navy, where Core and Premier members get free shipping on $50+, and All-Access cardmembers get free Standard shipping from $35. Free in-store pickup is also available.
Returns. Gap Inc.’s shared return policy gives you 30 days from the delivery date (online) or purchase date (in store). Higher Encore tiers get longer windows, but returns after 30 days receive a Merchandise Return Card (MRC) instead of a refund.
The return fee depends on membership. Gap Inc.’s Encore FAQ says mail returns are free for Encore Members. For nonmembers, $6 fee applies to each return package. Eligible* in-store returns and exchanges are free for all customers. Since Encore is free, it’s worth joining before you order.
Returns have to go back to Banana Republic, not Gap or Old Navy. Banana Republic Factory is treated as a separate brand, so factory purchases can’t be returned at regular BR stores.
Warranty. BR doesn’t offer a general product warranty. Gap Inc.’s policy says damaged or defective items may be returned at any time.
Is Banana Republic Worth It?
On sale, yes, especially for cashmere and trousers. A 100% cashmere sweater for $85 and a highly rated travel pant are good value when discounted.
At full price, it’s harder to justify. $160 for a lightweight cashmere crew is more than Quince charges, and some reviewers report pilling quickly. BR’s frequent sales mean you rarely need to pay the full amount.
Quality depends on the item. Natural-fiber pieces tend to get better reviews than stretch blends, and long-time customers disagree about whether the brand has improved. Read the reviews on each product page, and buy in-store when you can so you can feel the fabric first.
Where to Buy Banana Republic?
You can buy from bananarepublic.gap.com, the Banana Republic app, or Banana Republic stores. Store pickup is free and makes returns easier.
Banana Republic Factory sells lower-priced versions of BR styles, but reviewers note that factory quality is often lower than the main line. Some BR-branded items are also sold at Costco, where shoppers on Reddit describe the quality as lower.
The best time to buy is during sitewide events, which often include 40% off cashmere. Join Encore first so shipping and returns are free.
FAQs:
What is Banana Republic’s return policy?
You have 30 days from delivery for online orders, or from purchase for in-store orders. Higher Encore tiers get extra time, but late returns become store credit.
Does Banana Republic charge for returns?
Mail returns are free for Encore members and cost $6 per package for non-members. In-store returns and exchanges are free for everyone.
Does Banana Republic have free shipping?
Encore members get free shipping on orders of $50 or more. All-Access cardmembers get free Standard shipping from $35.
Is Banana Republic cashmere 100% cashmere?
Many of its cashmere sweaters are, including the two covered here. Always check the fabric line, since some BR sweaters are wool or cotton blends.
Does Banana Republic cashmere pill?
Some reviewers report pilling after one or two wears on the lightweight styles. Others say it washes well, so results vary.
Does Banana Republic offer free alterations?
All-Access cardmembers get free basic hemming on eligible pants, skirts and dresses bought from Banana Republic.
Is Banana Republic better quality than Gap?
Generally, yes. BR uses more natural fibers like cashmere, merino and linen, and costs more, though quality still varies by item.
Final Verdict: Is Banana Republic Worth the Price?
Banana Republic is a good choice if you want polished, natural-fiber clothing for work and you’re willing to buy during sales. Its cashmere sweaters and Traveler pants are the strongest products, and both get a lot of positive reviews.
Be careful at full price. Lightweight cashmere can pill, some long-time shoppers say quality has slipped, and cheaper brands like Quince sell similar basics for less. Join Encore so returns are free if something disappoints.
The best product to start with is the Cashmere Crew-Neck Sweater while it’s on sale. It’s 100% cashmere, highly rated, and well under its $160 regular price.



